Home truths for Barnet: Labour's Housing Commission report published

Home Truths for Barnet: tackling borough’s housing crisis and affordable homes shortage
Labour’s Housing Commission report: hope for residents who can’t afford to live in Barnet

A year-long study of Barnet’s housing crisis has come up with policy changes that would lead to a massive increase in the availability of affordable homes.

Home Truths for Barnet, the report of Barnet Labour Group’s Housing Commission, recommends alternatives to Barnet Council’s current housing policies, which have not built enough affordable housing in the past and will fail to meet the borough’s need for housing in the future.

Average property prices in Barnet of nearly £500,000 are 12 times the median household income, putting buying a home out of reach of local residents, and the median private sector rent of £310 a week is not affordable for half of the households in the borough.

Home Truths for Barnet is published today (Monday 25 January) after Barnet Homes, the council’s housing agency, revealed that the number of families made homeless after being evicted by private landlords has more than doubled in three years, from 700 in 2012 to 1,700 at the end of 2015. The total number of households accepted as homeless by Barnet and housed in emergency or temporary accommodation in September 2015 was 2,846, including 3,968 children.

The report’s key recommendations would make renting in Barnet more affordable for households on modest and low incomes, build 5,675 more affordable homes than currently planned and license private landlords so that private tenants are better protected from eviction and unreasonable rent increases.

The report recommends that:

· Social housing rents should be set at 30% to 50% of market rates, or £93 to £155 per week at current prices.

§ This compares with Barnet Council’s policy that the average rent for new council tenants should be £201 a week.

§ The definition of an “affordable” rent for planning purposes should be a third of net income, not up to 80% of market rates, or £248 per week, as it is now.

§ High rents in private and social housing have led to higher housing benefit claims, costing the council £263.8m in 2014/15 - an increase of 74 per cent since 2007/8.

· Half of all new homes built in Barnet should be affordable, with three in ten new homes built for social rent and two in ten built for ‘rent to buy’ or shared ownership.

§ The current target that 40 per cent of new homes should be affordable has been consistently missed by Barnet Council with only 1,123 “affordable” homes built in the three years 2011/12 to 2013/14, which was 30 per cent of all new homes.

§ On Barnet’s current projections for new housing, only 31 per cent or 8,690 of the 28,730 homes planned would be affordable, and only 19.7 per cent or 2,080 of homes with actual planning consent are affordable going forward. Labour’s recommendation would increase this to 50 per cent or 14,365, an increase of 5,675 affordable homes.

· Private sector landlords should be licensed by the council and a decent homes kitemark awarded to landlords meeting quality standards and minimum legal requirements.

§ About 37,000 households in Barnet or 26 per cent are private renters. The council forecasts this will rise to 35 per cent of all households by 2025.

§ Many councils have introduced licensing for the private rented sector, helping to tackle rogue landlords and enforce tenants’ rights.

§ The council doesn’t know how many private landlords rent housing in the borough because there is no registration or licensing scheme.

· Regeneration of existing council estates must benefit the residents who live there first.

§ Disastrous handling of estates regeneration in Barnet is leading to a net loss of 827 social homes for rent and longstanding residents not qualifying for new tenancies. On the West Hendon, leaseholders were originally offered less than half the value of their demolished properties, with the offer only upgraded after mass public protests and a public inquiry.

§ Regeneration plans for the Grahame Park estate in Colindale will lead to a net loss of 352 social rented homes, down from 1,428 to 1,076, alongside the building of 1,867 new private homes for sale and lease and 363 low-cost shared ownership homes.

The housing commission was set up by Barnet’s Labour councillors and has held seven public hearings and taken evidence from over 40 expert witnesses including housing professionals, London Boroughs and campaigners, and attracted over a hundred members of the public to its sessions since it first met in November 2014.

Nicky Gavron AM, Chair of the Housing Commission said:

I’m proud of what the Commission has achieved. We have produced a detailed piece of work which really lays bare the failings of Barnet council to look after the housing needs of its residents in both the public and private sectors.

"This report could not be more timely. The pernicious Housing and Planning Bill now going through Parliament will undermine the very foundations of affordable housing. Londoners will soon go to the polls in a mayoral election that is fast becoming a referendum on London’s housing.

"This report offers Barnet council a road map for getting housing back on track and offering a better future for its residents."

Cllr Ross Houston, Deputy Leader of Barnet’s Labour Group and housing spokesperson, who was vice-chair of the Commission, said:

“Barnet Council needs a massive change of direction if it is going to give local families any hope of a decent , affordable home.

“The council’s failure to plan for affordable housing or crack down on rogue landlords is making overcrowding, homelessness and poverty worse year after year.

“Our report shows there is a better way and that the council could meet the need for secure, affordable homes if it had the will to do so.”

Other recommendations in the report include:

- LB Barnet's Housing Needs Assessment must be reviewed.

- Capital housing subsidy for social rented homes should be restored.

- Publication of viability assessments for all housing developments should be made mandatory.

- The Housing Revenue Account borrowing cap should be lifted.

- The constraints on use of Right to Buy receipts to build more affordable homes should be removed.

- LB Barnet should establish a not-for-profit lettings agency

The full report can be downloaded here.

Notes to Editors:

The report is being launched at a public meeting this evening: 5pm 25 January at the Clayton Crown Hotel, Cricklewood Broadway with Guest Speaker Andrew Dismore AM.

Barnet Homes stated in December that the borough’s massive increase in the number of households officially accepted as homeless is largely due to evictions by private landlords. Barnet Homes said that 60 per cent of homeless families in September 2015 (1,707 out of 2,846) had been evicted by private landlords at the end of tenancies or because of rent arrears, compared with 30 per cent in September 2012 (697 out of 2,325).

Labour’s frontbench housing spokesperson John Healey MP published Government figures on Sunday (24 January) showing that the number of homeless households evicted by private landlords had risen 154 per cent since 2010:


For more information on the Housing Commission see:

For more information contact Cllr Ross Houston: cllr.r.houston@barnet.gov.uk
To contact the Barnet Labour Group: 020 8359 2568


Donate Volunteer Campaigns


get updates